You’re A Good Man, Charlie

Today, February 5, is my favorite (and only) brother Chuck’s birthday (aka Chucky, aka Charlie, aka Charles, aka CB). I almost got all sappy and posted a video of The Hollies singing “He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Brother.” But I decided to end this post with a much more meaningful video.

I was prepared to tell you how much my brother means to me. How much joy (and, OK, challenges) he has brought to my life. How much I’ve learned from him. How many fat lips he gave me over the years during his fits of temper, which are thankfully history. How every one of those fat lips was worth it, although it didn’t seem so at the time and, truthfully, I may be exaggerating their worth. How much we’ve all worried about him over the years. How it still isn’t easy sometimes, but how grateful I am that he has been able to live a fuller, more independent life than we ever imagined. How kind he can sometimes be. How much less anal-retentive I seem when I’m with him.


The Dowager Duchess will read just a bit of this to him (only the good parts) when he visits her on Sunday. All he’ll really care about are the photos, the video, and his moment of fame. I phone him every year on his birthday. He told me Sunday when we skyped that I “could call” if I want this year, too. In Chuck-speak, that means, “You’d better call or you’ll hear about it!”


The Part For Chuck

Happy birthday, little brother (you old fart)! I look forward to many more years of comedy routines with you.  Who’s on first? Why a duck? Say the secret word and I’ll give you a hundred of ’em. A hundred what? That’s a very good question; give me the answer and I’ll give you two hundred of ’em. Two hundred what? That’s a very good question…

Instead of some sappy song, I’d simply like to wish you a very happy birthday from me and “The Big Guy,” (oh, and from your nephews, Dudo and Moose). Don’t forget: Seven times thirteen is 28 (it’s really not). Get it right, Chuck, and you’re hired!

Author: Moving with Mitchell

From Brooklyn, New York; to North Massapequa; back to Brooklyn; Brockport, New York; back to Brooklyn... To Boston, Massachusetts, where I met Jerry... To Marina del Rey, California; Washington, DC; New Haven and Guilford, Connecticut; San Diego, San Francisco, Palm Springs, and Santa Barbara, California; Las Vegas, Nevada; Irvine, California; Sevilla, Spain. And Fuengirola, Málaga..

36 thoughts on “You’re A Good Man, Charlie”


    Love the video, Abbot and Costello are my all-time fave, CB!! They make me laugh every time I see them. 7 X 13 = 28 seems so logical now and I really think it's right…winkity wink!!

    Have a grand day and I see the smiles on both your Skype faces….all the best!!!Chuckie!

    Ron and Sophie

    1. Ron:
      Chuck loves all old-time comedy and slapstick. He never tires of Abbott & Costello, Marx Bros, Honeymooners. I think he's not got every DVD collection (complements of his brothers in Spain)!

  2. Brothers! Gotta love em!
    Happy Birthday Chuck! It must have been very difficult growing up with Mitchell!!You are truly a SAINT! And he owes you big time!!! lol
    Have a great day Chuck!

    1. Jo:
      He doesn't need much to be comfortable. He worked during the day and I called him in the evening. He was very happy to hear from us — laughed out loud when he heard San Geraldo yell "happy birthday" — and was hanging out at home for the evening.

Please share your thoughts...